August 28, 2026
Dear Port Jefferson Community,
We want to provide our community with a clear and accurate account of what has occurred regarding the Varsity Football program and our efforts to ensure that our student-athletes would have the opportunity to play this season.
We understand that many in our community first learned about our situation through the media. We had hoped to hear back from Section XI regarding our request to combine our football program with Rocky Point before communicating any definitive information to the community. Unfortunately, Section XI Executive Director Tom Combs chose to speak directly to the press about his decision, without providing the District with any formal, written communication about that decision or the reasons for it. As a result, we have been put in the position of playing catch-up and responding publicly to information that should have first been communicated to us in an official capacity.
Heading into this season, we anticipated 23 returning varsity players and eight (8) incoming freshmen. Unfortunately, that did not materialize. In fact, it was not until this past Wednesday that it became apparent, we would not have the required 16-player minimum to field a varsity team. This is the first time Port Jefferson has been unable to field a varsity squad.
While we were hoping we would reach the 16-player minimum, we also took the prudent step to prepare a backup plan to ensure that our students would have an opportunity to play football this season. Last week, we approached the Rocky Point School District about the possibility of combining our programs. Rocky Point was amenable to the concept, and our two districts quickly reached an agreement that would allow for both a combined varsity and junior varsity football program.
With that agreement in place, we submitted jointly with Rocky Point a proposal to Section XI and Mr. Combs. We fully expected our request to proceed through the normal Section XI process for combined teams. We were prepared to work cooperatively with Section XI on any logistical, scheduling or administrative requirements necessary to make the arrangement work. Instead, yesterday, we heard from multiple sources that our request was not going to be sanctioned by Section XI. In a Newsday article, Mr. Combs seemed to imply that this was based on the request coming in too late and the combined team potentially upsetting established power rankings, scheduling and divisional play. The fact is that the proposed Port Jefferson/Rocky Point varsity team would remain in Division III, and the Rocky Point schedule would remain in place. Rocky Point would be the host district. There would be no disruption to Division III play or to the existing schedule. Additionally, a combined Port Jefferson/Rocky Point team would have no impact on existing power rankings based on both teams’ won/loss records last season.
What is more concerning is the message that was communicated to Rocky Point yesterday. They were told by Mr. Combs that they would be excluded from postseason play if they proceeded with a combined varsity team. Notably, we were not informed of this penalty. It is also our understanding that no such penalty formally exists in Section XI rules and regulations. We were told that this is “a customary practice” of Section XI for late forming combined teams. In fact, this penalty has only been applied once in Section XI history. Faced with this consequence, Rocky Point had no alternative but to withdraw from the varsity portion of the agreement. Rocky Point has indicated they will continue with our agreement for the combined JV squad.
This whole matter and how it has transpired is deeply disappointing and troubling. Our students should not be caught in the middle of a dispute over administrative processes, power rankings or scheduling concerns. The Port Jefferson and Rocky Point districts came forward with a good-faith proposal designed to preserve opportunities for student-athletes in both communities. Without a combined varsity team, our high school student-athletes will not have a football season this year. For our seniors, who have invested years of their lives in this program, that prospect is particularly devastating.
As educators, our first responsibility must always be to our students. When there is a reasonable way to provide them with an opportunity to participate, particularly when that opportunity can be created without disrupting other schools or existing schedules, we believe every effort should be made to find a way forward. In this instance, this arbitrary decision to deny a combined Rocky Point/Port Jefferson varsity football program falls far below that standard.
We are not going to stop advocating for our students. The Port Jefferson School District will continue to pursue every possible avenue to enable our varsity football players to get on the field this year. We will continue to explore options, including formally petitioning Section XI for a written response, including clarification of the basis and authority for this decision, and the identification of the individual, committee or governing body that made this decision and determined the penalty of post-season exclusion.
Our football players have worked hard. They deserve the opportunity to play.
Sincerely,
Jessica Schmettan
Superintendent of Schools
Port Jefferson Union Free School District